Written By: Patrick David Sawyer
When it comes to open-back banjos, rim size is one of the first choices you’ll face—usually between an 11” or 12” pot. Both are standards in the industry, and while they might seem like a small difference on paper, they each bring a distinct tonal personality.
The 11” rim is punchy, bright, and focused. It’s got a classic, cutting tone that’s perfect for jam settings and for players who want a bit more snap and clarity. That tighter sound can really shine in group settings where you want to be heard.
The 12” rim, on the other hand, has a fuller, deeper voice. It’s rounder, warmer, and more open-sounding—great for solo playing, singing, or if you just prefer a richer, more resonant tone. Personally, I tend to prefer a 12” rim for standard or short scale banjos. The sound just feels more expressive and satisfying to me. That said, I still love an 11” rim for A-scales and long necks, where that tight, bright response can really bring upper register and lower register tunings to life.
But here’s the real truth: most of your tone comes from how you play. Your hand technique, whether heavy or light, shapes the sound more than the rim size. Then there’s the head material, head tension, tone ring, bridge, tailpiece—every part plays a role in the final tone. Rim size is just one element of a much bigger picture.
So how do you choose? Simple: go with what feels right to you. Listen with your own ears. Play as many banjos as you can. Borrow, test, experiment. And if you can’t decide? Well, most players end up with more than one banjo anyway. Having both 11” and 12” options gives you a versatile toolbox for different tunings, songs, and moods.
When I started building in the early 2000s, 11” rims were the go-to. They were what most players wanted. These days, 12” rims have taken the spotlight, especially among newer players. Tastes change, and that’s one of the things I love most about the banjo world—it’s always evolving.
Whatever sound you’re chasing, we can help you get there. Use our Pisgah Banjo Design Tool to build the banjo that fits your style, your ears, and your hands.
Because yes—size matters. But not as much as how it makes you feel when you play.
